
India China Boundry Issues - Book by Ranjait Singh Kalha
The personal and professional experience of Ranjit Singh Kalha, who has dealt with China for over 12 years, makes his book refreshingly different from many others on the boundary issue
ALTHOUGH there are many books on the complex issue of the unsettled boundary between India and China, Ambassador Ranjit Singh Kalha’s book is a welcome addition. Broadly, there are two schools of thought among scholars studying China. The first one worships China with such devotion that we need to coin a new word, sinolatry, along the lines of idolatry, to describe it. Examples of two books in this school readily come to mind. One is When China Rules the World: The End of the Western World Order and the Birth of a New Global Order by Martin Jacques, which came out in 2009. The other is Eclipse: Living under China’s Economic Dominance by Arvind Subramanian, who was recently appointed Chief Economic Adviser to the Government of India.
The second school, much less prolific and much less influential, propagates a sort of sinophobia, basically a mixture of hatred and fear of China. Kalha, neither sinolatrous nor sinophobic, is sober and scientific, and he writes with remarkable lucidity.
Kalha’s compulsory foreign language when he joined the Indian Foreign Service in 1965 was Chinese. In 1972, he was posted to China. He went to China via Hong Kong, and on the train in the mainland he asked for bacon as breakfast was being served. He was refused because some official had decided that the passenger was a Muslim and hence should not be served bacon.
Kalha’s showing his passport and declaring his Sikh identity did not change the decision. It is the personal and professional experience of the author, who has dealt with China for over 12 years, including three years of boundary negotiations, that makes this book refreshingly different from others.
Read the rest of this entry »
January 10th,2015 category:
Book Reviews,
Books |
No Comments
Nixon, Indira and India: Politics and Beyond
By Kalayani Shankar
Macmillan, Delhi , 2010
Pages 443, Rs.445
At a time when India is seen, rightly or wrongly, as intensely engaged in an effort to get closer and closer to United States, it is useful read this book by the well- known journalist and author Kalyani Shankar. The principal theme is how Indira Gandhi was crafty enough to outwit Richard Nixon ,himself a superb practitioner of the wicked art of real politik, in the context of the 1971 war between India and Pakistan bringing into being Bangladesh. Those of us who are old enough do have an idea of how Indira Gandhi did it. But Shankar by accessing the declassified US material and using her contacts with some of the major actors, including Henry Kissinger, has given us a reasonably comprehensive account of what happened and why it happened the way it happened.
Read the rest of this entry »
November 10th,2010 category:
Book Reviews,
Books,
International Affairs : Articles,
Politics,
Uncategorized | tags:
India,
Indira Gandhi,
Kalyani Shankar,
Politics,
Richard Nixon,
Soviet Union,
USA |
No Comments
Children of Abraham at War – The Clash of Messianic Militarisms
by Talmiz Ahmad
Aakar Books, Delhi, 2010
475 pages; Rs 1,250

Children of Abraham at War
A clash of prejudices
As I finished reading the book, I thought of two other books — Francis Fukuyama’s The End of History and Samuel Huntington’s The Clash of Civilizations. All three authors look for the big picture. Unlike the other two, however, the book under review is free from any trace of civilisational ego-centricism. Both Fukuyama and Huntington assume without providing much corroborating evidence the essential, inherent superiority of the western civilisation over others. Ambassador Talmiz Ahmed, currently posted to Saudi Arabia, is refreshingly free from such an ego-centric predicament, as historian Toynbee put it. Why is it that Ahmed is free and the other two are not? The answer is fairly simple. In addition to being an industrious scholar, the author has spent most of his 35-year career in West Asia. He has had the advantage of talking to a wide spectrum of people there, observing their behaviour and the interaction between the West and Islam.
Read the rest of this entry »
November 10th,2010 category:
Book Reviews,
Books,
International Affairs : Articles,
Politics,
Uncategorized | tags:
1967 War,
Apocalypticism,
CHILDREN OF ABRAHAM AT WAR,
Christianity,
Islam,
Messianism,
Millenialism,
Obama,
Pakistan,
Saudi Arabia,
Talmiz Ahmad,
USA |
No Comments
A Journey by Tony Blair
Hutchison, London, 2010
Pages 718, Rs. 999

A Journey by Tony Blair
Apologia for a war
Given that 92,000 copies were sold in the first four days, Tony Blair has felled a large number of trees to argue a case that is seriously flawed.
By sheer coincidence, as soon as the reviewer finished the book, the new Labour Party leader Ed Miliband came out with a categorical statement that the Iraq war was “wrong, wrong, wrong”. I had always thought that Tony Blair was really Tory Blair. I felt vindicated after reading the book written in the style of Christian apologetics to defend a position, not primarily to narrate what happened, how and why.
Read the rest of this entry »
November 10th,2010 category:
Book Reviews,
Books,
International Affairs : Articles,
Politics,
Uncategorized | tags:
A JOURNEY,
Bill Clinton,
Bush Administration,
European Issue,
International issues,
International relations,
Iraq War,
NATO,
Tony Blair,
U.K. |
1 Comment
By A.G. Noorani
Oxford University Press, Karachi
Pages 465, Rs. 795
Comrades in the Freedom Struggle
The book under review by the eminent scholar- cum- advocate A. G. Noorani was published in Pakistan and it will attract much attention and debate in India. Noorani’s thesis, argued with formidable skill and compelling documentary support, is that Jinnah started as a secular nationalist. The British considered him one among their most formidable opponents. Gandhi did not treat Jinnah courteously. Jinnah was opposed to Gandhi’s political philosophy and importing of religion into politics. Yet, Jinnah showed remarkable tact and patience and tried hard to work with the Congress till the Hindu fundamentalists in the Congress made it impossible for him to remain there with dignity.
Read the rest of this entry »
The Inheritance: The World Obama Confronts and the Challenges to American Power
Bantam Press, London 2009
Pages 498, Rs. 500

The Inheritance
Difficult Legacy
There is a frank admission that Bush messed it up. There is hope that Obama will undo the mess if he can get his act right. Is he getting it right?
DAVID E. SANGER is eminently qualified to write about what President Barack Hussein Obama has inherited from his predecessor. As the chief Washington correspondent of The New York Times, Sanger accompanied President George W. Bush on his official visits abroad and has had access to many of the world leaders Bush met with during his tenure.
Candidate Obama’s words “Yes, we can”, symbolising the paradigm shift he would make as President, resonated not only through the United States but also the rest of the world. The subtitle of the book reads The World Obama Confronts and the Challenges to American Power.
Read the rest of this entry »
By Jaswant Singh
Rupa and company
Pages 669, Rs. 695

India-Partition Independence
As I completed the enjoyable navigation through the ponderous, pompous, and pontificatory prose of Jaswant Singh, I was reminded of three other famous writers:
Oscar Wilde: The only duty we owe to history is to rewrite it.
Benedetto Croce: All historiography is contemporary historiography.
Voltaire: I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.
To put the last quotation in context, Voltaire is said to have said this to Helvetius after his book De l’esprit was burned in 1759.That was 30 years before the French Revolution began. One wonders whether Gujarat under Narendra Modi is in a pre-Revolutionary situation.
Read the rest of this entry »
Edited by Antony F.Lang, Jr. and John Williams
Palgrave Macmillan, New York
2005, pages 236
There are nine papers in all, written by six scholars, two of whom double up as editors. All the writers are university teachers, with four of them teaching International Relations(IR). Hannah Arendt never wrote on IR as such. But, the editors believe that it is possible to gain insights of value in IR from philosophers even if they do not directly theorize on IR. So far no attempt has been made to find out to what extent the ideas of Arendt can be invoked into IR. This book is the first such attempt.
Read the rest of this entry »
Conceptualized, designed and published by Global Media Insight