Fabian Blog
October 20th, 2017

India’s diplomacy is textual, not contextual

Ambassador K.P. FabianUnderstanding the rationale behind India’s diplomatic decisions is essential for policymakers and citizens alike, so as to take better decisions in the future. Gateway House interviews former Ambassador to Italy, K. P. Fabian, to discuss how India’s assessment of policy values the spoken word over context.

In his book, ‘Diplomacy, Indian Style,’ Fabian writes that “according to Greek mythology, Athena came out of the head of Zeus, fully grown and fully armed. There is a popular notion that India’s foreign policy came out of Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru’s head in a similar fashion. That notion is wrong.”

K. P. Fabian, former Indian Ambassador to Italy, shares his insights with Gateway House’s Rajeshwari Krishnamurthy on how the formulation of India’s foreign policies depends on the written word over circumstances.

Q. A common theme that runs through your book, Diplomacy: Indian Style, is of India’s diplomacy as being textual rather than contextual. Could you expand on this concept? How is it reflected in our current foreign policy?

When decisions are made using the textual approach, the written or spoken word is given more value, whereas in the case of the contextual approach, decisions are made after analysing the situation holistically.

The Simla Agreement of 1972 is a classic example of Indian diplomacy’s textual approach. Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi assumed that Pakistani President Zulfikar Ali Bhutto would keep his word, despite the fact that all his promises were made only verbally.

If we analyse our current foreign policy, it is evident that India is keen on signing agreements with Pakistan. I believe that people-to-people interaction and trade with Pakistan should be carried out, but the belief that Pakistan, because of such measures, will cooperate to maintain peace and positive neighbourly relations by coming to an agreement on Kashmir, is a naive approach.

Over the years, Pakistan has repeatedly proved that it will not settle for anything short of the whole of Kashmir. India, despite having known this, looks to find a solution.

In terms of pragmatic politics, no government in New Delhi will survive if it makes huge concessions on Kashmir to Pakistan.

Q. You also state that Pakistan engaged in more nimble diplomacy to get the better of India in past encounters, such as the diplomacy following the Bangladesh Liberation War of 1971. Given the strategic space it should have won through this, how would you rationalise the current state of disorder, internal and external, that Pakistan is in today?

One can say Pakistan engaged in nimble diplomacy because it managed to have good relations with the U.S. and China despite these two countries being at odds with each other for decades.

Another instance of Pakistan’s diplomatic smartness is that it has progressed with a gas pipe line from Iran despite U.S. concerns in the matter.

Although India has a rightful claim over Kashmir, the Pakistani propaganda – that the Kashmir issue is an instance of liberation struggle – has been successful by and large.

But by not trying hard to keep normal, good neighbourly relations with India, Pakistan’s diplomacy has been a failure. Irrational hatred for India has resulted in Pakistan’s tolerating and encouraging terrorism; first against India, and then in Afghanistan. This is one of the core reasons for their deteriorating relations with the U.S., which now ‘drones’ them, despite being an ally.

Ambassador K. P. Fabian served in the Indian Foreign Service between 1964 and 2000, during which time he was posted to Madagascar, Austria, Iran, Sri Lanka, Canada, Finland, Qatar, and Italy. Since leaving the service, Fabian has been active in the development sector. He is currently the President of AFPRO (Action For Food Production) and IGSSS (Indo-Global Social Service Society).

This article is part of the Ambassadors’ views, a collection of articles featuring eminent Indian diplomats written for Gateway House: Indian Council on Global Relations.

No Comments »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment


   

Conceptualized, designed and published by Global Media Insight

Search

Posts

August 21st, 2017

Qatar deserves kudos for handling crisis with maturity and logic


November 22nd, 2016

Triumphant Trump and American Foreign Policy


July 21st, 2016

The Attempted Coup in Turkey: What Next?


July 12th, 2016

The Chilcot Report on Blair and the War on Iraq


January 10th, 2015

Beyond the border - India China Boundary Issues


December 20th, 2014

The Middle Path


August 11th, 2014

Genocide in Gaza and Israel’s tunnel vision – analysis


July 28th, 2014

Israeli impunity and global helplessness


July 2nd, 2014

Can Iraq’s disintegration be prevented?


June 30th, 2014

V. K. Krishna Menon Memorial Lecture 2014


March 20th, 2014

Chess Game over Crimea


March 6th, 2014

Italy Erred in Dealing with Marines Case


February 20th, 2014

Where is Egypt going?


September 12th, 2013

Book Review: AN UNCERTAIN GLORY


August 15th, 2013

Book Review: INDIA’S FOREIGN POLICY


July 21st, 2013

Book Review: SAMUDRA MANTHAN


May 5th, 2013

Book Review: MANAGING INDIA’S NUCLEAR FORCES


July 30th, 2012

India’s diplomacy is textual, not contextual


March 18th, 2012

Handling terrorism, US style: The march of folly continues


March 7th, 2012

Will Israel attack Iran? It cannot be ruled out.


February 14th, 2011

DEVELOPMENT, JUSTICE, AND DEMOCRACY: SOME REFLECTIONS


November 10th, 2010

NIXON, INDIRA AND INDIA: Politics and Beyond


November 10th, 2010

Book Review: CHILDREN OF ABRAHAM AT WAR


November 10th, 2010

Book Review: A JOURNEY


July 7th, 2010

Book Review: JINNAH AND TILAK: Comrades in the Freedom Struggle


October 29th, 2009

Book Review: THE INHERITANCE


October 4th, 2009

Aristotle vs. Greenspan


October 4th, 2009

Book Review : JINNAH : India-Partition Independence


April 15th, 2009

President Obama: Plans and Impediments


March 5th, 2009

A talk about Mahatma Gandhi


March 5th, 2009

Book Review : The Lexus and the Olive tree: Understanding Globalisation by Thomas L. Friedman


March 5th, 2009

Most unpopular war in history


March 5th, 2009

Book Review: Hannah Arendt and International Relations


March 5th, 2009

India at sixty


March 5th, 2009

Commonsense on terror


Comments

Category

Links

Archives

Reading Corner

Tag Cloud

Blog Feeds